A Critical Review of Trypsin Digestion for LC-MS Based Proteomics

Proteomics is defined as the large-scale study of proteins in particular for their structures and functions (Anderson and Anderson 1998), and investigations of proteins have become very important since they are the main components of the physiological metabolic pathways in eukaryotic cells. Proteomics increasingly plays an important role in areas like protein interaction studies, biomarker discovery, cancer prevention, drug treatment and disease screening medical diagnostics (Capelo et al. 2009). Proteomics can be performed either in a comprehensive or “shotgun” mode, where proteins are identified in complex mixtures, or as “targeted proteomics” where “selective reaction monitoring” (SRM) is used to choose in advance the proteins to observe, and then measuring them accurately, by optimizing the sample preparation as well as the LC-MS method in accordance to the specific proteins (Mitchell 2010). Whether “MS-based shotgun proteomics” has accomplished anything at all regarding clinically useful results was recently addressed by Peter Mitchell in a feature article (Mitchell 2010), and he states that the field needs to make a further step or even change direction. Referring to discussions with among others John Yates and Matthias Mann, Mitchell addresses the failure in the search for biomarkers as indicators of disease, the difficulties of protein arrays, the uncertainty of quantification in “shotgun proteomics” (due to among others the efficiency of ionization in the mass spectrometers), database shortcomings, the problems of detecting post translational modifications (PTMs), and finally the huge disappointment in the area of drug discovery. The field points in the direction of targeted proteomics, but targeted proteomics will not be the solution to all our questions and comprehensive proteomics will still be needed. In order to get as much information, with as high quality as possible, from a biological sample, both the sample preparation and the final LC-MS analyses need to be optimized. The most important step in the sample preparation for proteomics is the conversion of proteins to peptides and in most cases trypsin is used as enzyme. Trypsin is a protease that specifically cleaves the proteins creating peptides both in the preferred mass range for MS sequencing and with a basic residue at the carboxyl terminus of the peptide, producing information-rich, easily interpretable peptide fragmentation mass spectra. Some other proteases can be used as well, such as Lys-C, which is active in more harsh conditions with 8 M urea, and give larger fragments than trypsin. Asp-N and Glu-C are also highly sequence-